Expert Speak Terra Nova
Published on Sep 07, 2022 Updated 15 Days ago
India is on the right track as it sets up carbon markets and launches of pilot ETS schemes for particulate matter in different states.
Confronting air pollution by setting up carbon markets

Millions of people in India inhale severely polluted air, full of PM2.5 particles along with toxic gases like carbon monoxide, sulphur dioxide, and nitrogen dioxide. According to IQ Air, India was the fifth most polluted country in the world in 2021, with PM2.5 levels that were 11 times higher than the WHO’s guideline value. The World Air Quality Report states that 63 cities in India were amongst the top 100 most polluted places in the world, with 10 Indian cities ranking in the top 15. Data from the Energy Policy Institute at the University of Chicago suggested that people living in Delhi could add up to 10 years to their lives if  PM2.5 levels are brought down to the mandated WHO guideline levels. Moreover, a study done by the Lancet Commission on Pollution and Health revealed that air pollution was responsible for a whopping 16.7 lakh deaths in 2019—almost 17.8 percent of all deaths in India that year.

All statistics indicate that India’s PM2.5 levels are a major concern, in terms of the impact it has on our economy, workforce, and the standard of life of its citizens.

All statistics indicate that India’s PM2.5 levels are a major concern, in terms of the impact it has on our economy, workforce, and the standard of life of its citizens. Addressing this issue requires a critical analysis of the causes behind this problem, i.e., the major contributors to air pollution, especially PM2.5 particles, in India. Researchers from the Washington University in St Louis conducted a study to record PM2.5 exposure and the sectoral contributions to PM2.5 levels in different countries, including India. Their analysis revealed that all residential and commercial cooking, lighting, and heating was the major source of PM2.5 matter, accounting for 28 percent of PM2.5 levels in India in 2017. Industrial activity was the second largest contributor accounting for 15 percent of PM2.5 matter in India’s atmosphere. Moreover, industrial processes are also leading contributors of harmful nitrogen and sulphur compounds in the air, which have severe short- and long-term consequences. Consequently, targeted intervention to reduce the emission of pollutants by the industrial sector could go a long way in reducing air pollution in India.

Figure 1

Source: https://urbanemissions.info/india-air-quality/india-satpm25/

The Indian government has taken steps in the right direction recently. The Lok Sabha tabled the Energy Conservation (Amendment) Bill, 2022 last month to amend the Energy Conservation Act (ECA), 2001 and this bill was passed on 8 August 2022. Intended to bring a renewed focus on sustainability and support India’s transition to a net-zero economy by 2070, the Act has several provisions to effectively decarbonise India. Most notably, the Act empowers the Government of India (GoI) to establish a carbon credit trading scheme in India, and thus, establish a legal framework to create India’s first-ever compliance carbon trading market. This decision will likely have a huge impact on India’s industrial sector and could lead to reductions in industrial emissions, increased investments in clean energy, and increased energy efficiency amongst private sector firms.

Emission Markets Explained

At their core, emission trading systems (ETS) put a price on emissions of harmful gases such as CO2, N2O, etc. to internalise the negative external effect they have on people. In other words, firms which release these gases during their industrial process are held accountable and are taxed for these emissions, to account for the harmful impact they have on people’s health. These markets are meant to incentivise firms to innovate and transition to cleaner, eco-friendly industrial processes which lead to cleaner air for the general populace, whilst generating significant revenue for the government—a win-win situation for all.

The most common form of emission market in practice is cap-and-trade models, wherein the government sets an overall ‘cap’ on the total emissions from a specific industrial sector. The government then allocates or auctions permits to regulated firms, giving the firms the right to emit a specified amount of pollutants. These permits can be traded freely on environmental exchanges, and the market forces of supply and demand fix a specific price for these permits. If firms exceed their allowance of emissions, they are severely fined. Over time, the government lowers the overall cap so that total emissions will fall.

The most common form of emission market in practice is cap-and-trade models, wherein the government sets an overall ‘cap’ on the total emissions from a specific industrial sector.

Thus, emission markets utilise a carrot-and-stick-approach to catalyse the transition to the green economy:

  1. By forcing firms to purchase these permits to release emissions, the government increases the cost of production for these firms. Accordingly, firms which can transition to cleaner production processes can lower costs and secure a competitive advantage.
  2. Moreover, firms that can make this transition quicker are able to secure higher profits, as they can sell their unused permits on the exchange and earn additional revenue.

ETS initiatives have been implemented around the world for a long time, with the EU-ETS scheme being the first international carbon market established in 2005. Currently, there are 32 ETS initiatives in place around the world, covering 38 national and 31 subnational jurisdictions. Notably, China, the world’s largest emitter of greenhouse gases, implemented its own mandatory ETS initiative in 2021 and is currently home to the world’s largest carbon market.

ETS and Air Pollution

While the main focus of ETS initiatives is to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and tackle global warming, they can also play a key role in reducing air pollution through direct and indirect channels. Some of the key ways in which ETS schemes can lead to cleaner air include:

  1. ETS initiatives incentivise firms to develop innovative, eco-friendly industrial processes which emit fewer polluting agents such as greenhouse gases, toxic emissions, etc. For instance, in the European Union (EU), as a result of the implementation of the EU-ETS scheme, more than 188 cleantech patents were filed between 2005-2016, corresponding to an 8.1-percent increase in patenting by regulated firms.
  2. Through catalysing the transition to cleaner industrial processes, ETS initiatives have been found to decrease PM5 emissions by industries as well. One study found that Chinese ETS initiatives reduced PM2.5 levels by 4.8 percent between 2005-2017. This reduction in PM2.5concentration caused by China's ETS may have avoided 23,363 deaths and saved US$41.38 billion annually in GDP. Moreover, these benefits spill over to neighbouring regions and cities, especially those which are located downwind from regulated industrial units.
  3. Carbon markets have also resulted in a synergistic reduction in the emission of other pollutants such as harmful sulphur and nitrogen compounds. A study found that China’s carbon emission trading policy reduced both the amount of SO2 emitted and the intensity of these emissions, supporting the transition towards a green economy.
  4. Establishment of a carbon market requires strengthening the monitoring, verification and reporting (MRV) mechanisms to track emissions throughout the country. Superior MRV systems can provide more accurate, real-time data on harmful emissions which would allow the government to launch better-tailored, effective programmes to reduce harmful emissions across different regions.
  5. ETS initiatives are not limited to trading carbon permits, but can also be extended to other harmful pollutants and particulate matter. Creating carbon markets would also create the infrastructure required to create market exchanges for SO2 and NOx permits, resulting in a direct decrease in these emissions. The Acid Rain Programme in the US is an example of a market-based cap-and-trade system designed to reduce harmful sulphur and nitrogen emissions by the power sector. Along with other programs, the Acid Rain Programme was responsible for annual SO2reductions of over 93 percent and annual NOX emissions reductions of over 87 percent—a huge success.

ETS pilots aimed at reducing particulate have already been piloted in India and have yielded promising results. In Gujarat, the Gujarat Pollution Control Board (GPCB) along with researchers from the Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab (JPAL) and The Energy Institute at the University of Chicago launched the world’s first ETS scheme for particulate matter (PM10) in 2019. The experiment has resulted in a 24-percent reduction in PM10 pollution, with over 90 percent of the regulated plants providing data on pollution. With the success of the pilot in Gujarat, pilots are also being organised in other regions, including Punjab.

ETS initiatives have proven to be effective in reducing carbon emissions—the EU-ETS scheme has decreased carbon emissions by 43 percent since 2005.

ETS initiatives have proven to be effective in reducing carbon emissions—the EU-ETS scheme has decreased carbon emissions by 43 percent since 2005. However, the co-benefits of these schemes, especially in terms of reducing the toxic gas emissions and stimulating eco-friendly innovation, are often overlooked. Moreover, using a similar framework for particulate matter, governments can tackle air pollution via a new, highly effective mechanism.

It is noteworthy to say that ETS initiatives on their own cannot solve India’s air pollution problem. While a useful tool to tackle industrial emissions, these schemes do not address pollution from other sources, such as crop burning, household fuel consumption, and the transport sector. The government needs to scale up funding for existing air pollution reduction programmes, such as the National Clean Air Programme (NCAP), and launch more targeted interventions to tackle the different facets of this issue effectively. However, by paving the way for the creation of carbon markets in India, and with the launch of pilot ETS schemes for particulate matter in different states, India seems to be on the right path to address its air pollution problem.

The views expressed above belong to the author(s). ORF research and analyses now available on Telegram! Click here to access our curated content — blogs, longforms and interviews.