Event ReportsPublished on Jun 03, 2010
The study urges urgent action to improve the state of sanitation and demands facilities comparable to those at airports
ORF study highlights appalling state of sanitation at Mumbai railway stations
A first-of-its-kind study of sanitation facilities and the state of cleanliness at all of Mumbai’s 109 suburban railway stations, undertaken by Observer Research Foundation (ORF) Mumbai, has revealed shocking shortfalls in this most basic commuter amenity.

The survey-based study has unmasked the wretched condition of toilets and urinals in most of the stations on Central, Western and Harbour lines, which people – especially women commuters – often are forced to avoid due to their terrible state of neglect.

Releasing the study report in Mumbai on 2 June, ORF Mumbai chairman Sudheendra Kulkarni said the sanitation facilities at railway stations should be comparable to those at airports, which have undergone major improvement in recent years. “Why should there be this kind of ‘caste discrimination’ between air and train passengers?”  he asked.

Mumbai’s suburban rail network, which carries 6.3 million commuters every day, is the city’s lifeline. It is also the city’s pride. The Central and Western Railways deserve praise for running the suburban service, against several odds, with a high degree of punctuality and safety. However, provision of adequate number of clean sanitation facilities does not seem to be a priority for the railway authorities.

The entire suburban railway network – from Churchgate to Dahanu Road on Western Railway; from CST to Kasara-Khopoli on Central Railway; and from CST to Panvel on the Harbour Line – has a provision of only 355 toilet seats and 673 urinals. By the standards of the best suburban railway networks in USA, the UK and even China, the Mumbai Suburban Rail Network should have 12,600 toilet seats to serve the needs of its commuters. Thus, the shortfall is more than 12,000 toilet seats!

The ORF study reveals that the situation in qualitative terms is even worse. The standard of cleanliness and maintenance at most railway toilets and urinals is deplorable, so much so that the facilities are used only by those who are desperate. Most regular commuters, especially women commuters, go to great lengths to avoid using them altogether, choosing in the process to inflict much suffering on themselves. For women, this means not drinking water before traveling, which puts their health at risk.

According to Dr. Kamaxi Bhate, Associate Professor at the Department of Preventive and Social Medicine, KEM Hospital, lack of access to clean toilets and urinals at Mumbai’s railway stations is one of the main reasons for high levels of urinary tract infections (UTI) among female train commuters. “This is the reason for UTI being more common among women than men, the differential ratio of incidence being 6:1. Repeated bouts of UTI make women vulnerable to anaemia and urinary stones.”

The ORF survey revealed that only “17% of the total number of toilets at suburban stations are meant for women.” Worse still, “93% of the toilets that were found to be ‘closed’ or ‘out of use’ are those intended for women.”

Apart from the obvious lack of political will, underinvestment by the Indian Railways is one of the main reasons for the pathetic state of sanitation and cleanliness.  The ORF study has revealed that the annual sanitation budget for the construction of new toilets at Central Railway’s 73 stations in 2008-09 was a paltry Rs. 14 lakh! Similarly, the total annual capital expenditure on passenger amenities on the Western Railway suburban network in 2006-07 was Rs. 1.47 crore, with not a single penny spent on improving sanitation. Such low investment amounts to gross injustice towards Mumbai, which unfortunately has gone unprotected by the political parties and elected representatives in the city.

The ORF study also highlighted that a staggering 20,000 commuters died on Mumbai’s railway tracks in the last five years -- nearly ten commuters die each day. It said “Although there are several other reasons for this shocking and disgraceful tragedy in Mumbai that goes on year after year, a significant number of those killed or injured or slum dwellers who lack community toilets and hence use railway tracks to relieve themselves.”

ORF’s recommends for improving the situation:

• Changes in the Indian Railways’ policy on sanitation so that the GMs and DMs in CR and WR are suitably empowered to take decisions that are appropriate to meet Mumbai’s needs.

• Developing a ‘Dedicated Sanitation and Passenger Amenities Fund’ to finance sanitation and other passenger amenities projects. “With 63 lakh commuters using the suburban system each day, a surcharge of only 30 paise per passenger per day (that is, Rs. 100 per passenger per year) would create a fund of Rs. 63 crore, which is sufficient to bring about a marked improvement.”

• Redesigning of railway stations to make space for new toilets and urinals in a more aesthetic and functional manner.

• Special Commissioners for Passenger Amenities.

• Since the departmental staff of Railways cannot provide satisfactory sanitation and cleanliness services, Central and Western Railways should expand the use of PPP models for attracting better private players with a track record of providing superior sanitation services. Suitable incentives should be given to them including advertising revenue, user charges, service contracts, etc.

• Greater encouragement for NGOs in the sanitation sector, Corporates’ CSR activities, and community participation models to engage and empower local actors

• Setting higher benchmarks for water conservation; Encouraging stations to practice the ‘3-R principle -- Reduce, Re-use, and Recycle – in respect of water and solid waste management.

• Using innovative technologies like bio-sanitizers to aid waterless cleaning etc.

• Investing resources in passenger education in the form of I-E-C campaigns; Creating an ‘Empowered Citizen’s Monitoring Committee’ for every station to increase accountability, transparency and local monitoring through cooperation.

ORF’s study lays strong emphasis on the need for better cooperation and coordination between the Railway authorities, the State Government and Municipal Corporations in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region to improve sanitation and other passenger amenities to world-class levels.

Report Version: English and Marathi

The views expressed above belong to the author(s). ORF research and analyses now available on Telegram! Click here to access our curated content — blogs, longforms and interviews.