South-First Connectivity: The Malacca Strait’s Strategic Role

Image Source: Wikipedia

This is part of the essay series: Sagarmanthan Edit 2025.

As global trade transitions into a new era defined by supply chain realignments, resource competition, and shifting geopolitical alliances, maritime chokepoints are being reexamined through the lens of connectivity. The Strait of Malacca, often referred to as the “maritime Silk Road’s throat,” remains pivotal in global logistics. Stretching 800 kilometers between the Malay Peninsula and the Indonesian island of Sumatra, this narrow but vital waterway is a cornerstone of global seaborne trade. It is here that the interplay of new materials, emerging markets, and dynamic geopolitics converge, reshaping the contours of connectivity in the Indo-Pacific and beyond.

The Geostrategic Importance of the Malacca Strait

The Malacca Strait serves as the shortest maritime route between the Indian and Pacific Oceans, facilitating the movement of an estimated 82,000 vessels annually. Over 40 percent of global trade passes through this channel, including 80 percent of China's crude oil imports and much of the energy supplies to Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan. This critical link between the resource-rich Middle East and Asia’s manufacturing powerhouses underscores its status as the world’s second-busiest chokepoint after the English Channel, but far more vita in terms of energy security and supply chain efficiency.

The Malacca Strait serves as the shortest maritime route between the Indian and Pacific Oceans, facilitating the movement of an estimated 82,000 vessels annually.

The term “Malacca Dilemma” has become embedded in China’s strategic discourse, underscoring the country’s dependence on the Strait and its susceptibility to potential blockades or disruptions. Any interruption, whether arising from geopolitical tensions, piracy, or natural disasters, would carry significant implications for global energy markets and the stability of international supply chains.

Role in Developing Littoral States’ Economies and Policies

The economies of Singapore, Malaysia, and Indonesia (the three littoral states) are intricately tied to the strait’s activity. Singapore, home to the world’s second-busiest port, has transformed into a global maritime and logistics hub. Malaysia, with ports like Port Klang and Tanjung Pelepas, has become a key transhipment centre. Indonesia is revitalising its maritime identity through initiatives such as the Global Maritime Fulcrum.

The Malacca Strait also influences the regional policy landscape, particularly in areas such as port congestion, environmental sustainability, trade facilitation, and maritime governance. Collaboration under initiatives like the Cooperative Mechanism on Safety of Navigation and Environmental Protection in the Straits of Malacca and Singapore (CM-SOM) exemplifies regional policy coordination.

Performance Indicators of Key Shipping Ports Surrounding the Strait

Several ports around the strait serve as vital transhipment and trade gateways. Performance can be assessed through indicators such as container throughput, berth productivity, and logistic performance indices:

Table 1: Performance Indicators of Key Ports of the Malacca Strait

Source: Alphaliner (2024). Global Container Port Throughput 2023. Alphaliner Monthly Monitor.

Table 1 shows a tiered port network anchored by the Malacca Strait, with Singapore serving as a premier global hub, Malaysia’s Port Klang and Tanjung Pelepas operating as major transhipment alternatives, and Indonesia’s smaller Belawan port deepening regional integration. Together, they underscore the Strait’s central role in the Global South’s maritime transformation, bolstered by the adoption of smart technologies like blockchain cargo tracking and AI-driven logistics.

Malaysia’s Port Klang and Tanjung Pelepas serve as key transhipment centres, offering efficient alternatives to congested ports. 

The data reveals a tiered port structure centred around the Malacca Strait. Singapore’s leading throughput confirms its dominance as a regional and global maritime hub. Malaysia’s Port Klang and Tanjung Pelepas serve as key transhipment centres, offering efficient alternatives to congested ports. Meanwhile, Indonesia’s Belawan, though smaller, reflects growing integration with regional trade. Collectively, these ports illustrate how the Malacca Strait remains a critical platform for the Global South’s maritime economic transformation. These ports have increasingly integrated smart technologies, including blockchain-based cargo tracking and AI-driven logistics optimisation.

The Evolution of Global Maritime Trade Flows Through the Strait

Trade through the Malacca Strait is being reshaped by three defining trends. First, trade flows are diversifying toward containerised cargo and intermediate goods, reflecting the fragmentation of production networks. This has made the Strait indispensable not only for finished goods but also for essential components moving between Asia’s manufacturing hubs.

Second, China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has reinforced the strait’s connectivity by improving regional port and rail linkages. These infrastructure investments (from inland logistics corridors to expanded port capacity) are not circumventing the strait but reinforcing its central role in East-West trade, particularly through Port Klang and Tanjung Pelepas.

Third, the green transition has intensified trade in critical minerals like lithium, cobalt, and rare earths. Southeast Asia has become a vital processing and transit hub, and the Malacca Strait is central to transporting both traditional fossil fuels and these new strategic materials. According to the EIA (2023), the strait transports over 20 million barrels of oil daily, underscoring its enduring energy relevance.

Southeast Asia has become a vital processing and transit hub, and the Malacca Strait is central to transporting both traditional fossil fuels and these new strategic materials.

These transformations, alongside vessel upsizing, shifting demand centres, and tighter environmental regulations, only deepen the Malacca Strait’s role as a consolidation point for evolving global supply chains. Even with trends like reshoring or the rise of alternative routes, the Strait remains the connective tissue of South-South trade and a pivot of maritime resilience in a re-globalising world.

Over the past two decades, trade through the Strait of Malacca has adapted to global economic shifts and supply chain realignments. Traffic has diversified toward containerised cargo and intermediate goods, while Belt and Road Initiative investments in ports and rail have strengthened access to the strait. At the same time, the green transition has spurred growing flows of critical minerals such as rare earths and lithium.

Figure 1:  The development of ship traffic crossing the Strait of Malacca by ship type from 2010 to 2022.

Source: MEH (2024) Total Number of Ships Passing Through the Strait of Malacca from 2000 to 2022, Retrieved July 22, 2025.

Map No. (1): Average volume of oil transported through global sea straits in 2023 (million barrels per day)

Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) analysis, based on Vortexa tanker tracking and Panama Canal Authority, using EIA conversion factors and calculations

The Security and Military Importance of the Malacca Strait

Security in the Strait of Malacca remains a concern despite trilateral patrols by Indonesia, Malaysia, and Singapore significantly curbing piracy since the mid-2000s. Non-traditional threats, ranging from maritime terrorism and human trafficking to smuggling and cybersecurity risks, persist, while the strait’s strategic value has drawn intensified naval presence from the U.S., China, India, and Japan, spurring submarine activity, A2/AD strategies, and heightened regional tensions.

Potential Alternative Routes to the Malacca Strait

Several alternatives have been proposed or are under development to reduce reliance on the Strait of Malacca.

While none can fully replicate the capacity and efficiency of the Malacca Strait, these routes highlight strategic hedging and the desire for supply chain resilience in an increasingly multipolar world. However, even amid these efforts, the Strait retains a structural centrality that is difficult to match, particularly for South-South trade. Its proximity to major emerging markets and its deeply entrenched role in linking energy exporters with Asian manufacturing hubs give it enduring significance that alternative routes cannot easily replicate. However, despite growing interest in redundancy and diversification, these alternatives remain insufficient in several key respects. Many are constrained by physical geography, extreme climate, or unresolved geopolitical tensions. Others lack the robust port infrastructure, integrated intermodal systems, or economies of scale that make the Malacca Strait uniquely efficient and cost-effective.

Furthermore, the Strait’s central location, linking Asia’s largest manufacturing hubs to energy suppliers and consumer markets, continues to give it unparalleled strategic value. While strategic competition may encourage experimentation with alternative corridors, the Malacca Strait remains the irreplaceable backbone of Indo-Pacific maritime connectivity. Several alternatives have been proposed or are under development to reduce reliance on the Strait of Malacca:

Table 2: Strategic Alternatives to the Strait of Malacca – Routes, Characteristics, and Status

Source: This table has been compiled by the author. Source information for each route has been hyperlinked to the route name within the table.

Map No. (2): The most significant alternative straits to the Strait of Malacca.

Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) analysis, based on Vortexa tanker tracking and Panama Canal Authority, using EIA conversion factors and calculations

Conclusion

As the world rethinks connectivity in light of green transitions, technological revolutions, and geopolitical flux, the Malacca Strait’s relevance endures and expands. It not only moves goods but shapes the destinies of nations, influences policy agendas, and determines strategic alignments. To navigate the complexities of new materials, new markets, and new politics, regional cooperation, infrastructure innovation, and adaptive governance of the Malacca Strait will be paramount.

The future of maritime trade may indeed pivot on how this single, narrow corridor evolves and how the world prepares for what lies beyond it.

Anas Rakha is a Senior Maritime Researcher at the Suez Canal Authority. As a maritime economist, he specialises in global trade routes, port strategy, and geoeconomic policy.

• Maritime Security
• India
• alternative routes
• Belt and Road Initiative
• energy security
• global supply chains
• Indo-Pacific trade
• Malacca Strait connectivity
• maritime chokepoint
• maritime logistics
• South-South trade
• Southeast Asia ports

The views expressed above belong to the author(s). ORF research and analyses now available on Telegram! Click here to access our curated content — blogs, longforms and interviews.

PREV NEXT