Author : Oommen C. Kurian

Expert Speak Health Express
Published on Apr 22, 2020
Bend it like Kerala: How an Indian state is holding its own against COVID19

It was 3 March. The alarm bells hadn’t started ringing yet in India; a country with six confirmed cases, three of them in Kerala. “Things have changed. We now need to be worried about community spread;” a retired health bureaucrat from the state shared at a public event hosted by the Observer Research Foundation and the Chinese Consulate in Mumbai. He was referring to the spread of coronavirus in the Middle East and how it meant trouble for Kerala, and India.

Within a few weeks the nationwide number had increased to 17,000, with cities including Mumbai showing thousands of cases and several hospitals shutting down in panic. Over the same time, Kerala – a relatively prosperous state on the southern tip of the subcontinent – would start to “flatten the curve”. The “Kerala model” is already being held up around the world as a success story. How did it do it?

First, Kerala started from a strong baseline. Its socio-economic development is an example of what investments in human capital can do for poverty reduction and prosperity. Compared to the rest of India, it has vastly higher literacy rates and better health outcomes; its vibrant polity is often dominated by communist rhetoric, but the policies remain moderately social democratic. Some of its strengths are also weaknesses: skilled workers are the state’s major export – it receives more remittances from abroad than anywhere else in India, much of which comes from the Middle East – and it is a large tourism hub. These are two factors that expose its inhabitants to a greater risk of transmission.

The first three confirmed patients in Kerala were students from Wuhan who had retuned home during the Chinese New Year week. In addition, there were hundreds of people evacuated by the Indian government by the Indian government from Wuhan and quarantined during early February. Thankfully, none of them tested positive. However, as feared, the following weeks saw a high number of infections in Kerala and the confirmed number of cases increased to more than 100 by 24 March. Kerala by then had one-fifth of Indian cases, despite having only 2.5% of India’s population. Right now, Kerala has just around 2.5% of the Indian case-load.

The reason Kerala has managed to come out the other side so quickly is because of its strong public health system, clear risk communication and community participation. What doesn’t get discussed often is that Kerala is one of the most privatized health systems in India. However, it has led to a healthy division of labour between the public and the private sectors. Public health functions are given a lot of government attention and this very decentralised system has withstood the test of two serious floods and another viral outbreak in recent years, often making good use of the voluntary and active engagement of the public.

Kerala’s efforts to address the pandemic had started as early as January. Indeed, its experience of dealing with the Nipah outbreak in 2018, a virus that had neither treatment nor vaccine available, came in handy. Learning from this episode, which saw a high proportion of hospital-acquired infections, the system had effective protocols in place, and stuck to the time-tested strategy of case isolation and contact-tracing, combined with an alert community surveillance system. Tens of thousands of people were in home quarantine this time, with compliance made possible via a mix of phone-based monitoring and neighbourhood watch initiatives.

A severe lockdown was implemented before the national one, schools were shut, gatherings were banned, a stricter and longer quarantine than the national norm was deployed, and a few pious people who still insisted on praying in groups were even arrested. But it was not just a China-like iron fist alone that drove actions of the government led by a communist party. It was matched by socially valuable outreach policies. Supplies were home-delivered, midday meals from schools were sent to children even when schools were shut, regular and clear communication channels were established to dispel fake news, migrant labourers from other states were well taken care of, and mental health helplines were established across the state. The “break the chain” campaign to limit the Covid-19 spread was particularly successful.

When unexpected events – like a family from Italy skipping airport screening in Pathanamthitta, or the many returnees from the infamous Nizamuddin incident – potentially exposed hundreds of people to infection, thousands of state-employed health workers and volunteers equipped with maps and flowcharts conducted aggressive contact-tracing and brought the situation under control. Kerala’s has been an all-of-government, all-of-society approach, with even students chipping in, building walk-in kiosks for taking samples, inspired by the South Korean model. In addition to using the centrally procured real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) testing kits, Kerala was the first state to procure rapid test kits from the Pune-based Mylab.

For most people, Covid-19 is a mild infection that can go away without treatment and can, therefore, be missed easily. It is deadly perhaps also for the same reason. As rich, muscular hospital systems across the world – which have opted for a spaghetti western-style standoff with the coronavirus – are quickly getting overrun, perhaps there are lessons to be learned from the nimble-footed, community-oriented, cautiously aggressive approach that Kerala opted for, with great initial results in terms of slowing the spread and limiting deaths.

Through the last few months it was learnt that the true success of a health system is whether it is able to protect the old and the infirm, and the true indicator of the spread of the pandemic is the number of deaths. Kerala has done remarkably well on both counts; part chance but mostly hard work. For a state that had its first patient in January, the profile of patients (more than 90% under 60 years old, thanks to social-distancing protecting the old) as well as the number of deaths (just three), are nothing but impressive.

Two districts from Kerala, namely Pathanamthitta and Kasaragod, are now seen as models of containment. With India’s COVID-19 cases and deaths crossing 17,000 and 500 respectively, thankfully, there are other Indian districts that deployed innovative and aggressive strategies to contain the spread like Bhilwara in Rajasthan and Agra in Uttar Pradesh. The situation remains dynamic, and some gains Agra made were lost in a surge in the last few days.

While the curve has been flattened for now and transmission limited, the fact remains that Kerala is also riding the tiger of a strict economic lockdown with the rest of the country, and deriving temporary benefits. Kerala aims to lift restrictions soon – a move that New Delhi has condemned. How it manages to climb down safely from the strict lockdown will depend on a large number of factors. The summer monsoon rains, the floods that will follow, as well as returning migrants will add layers of complexity. But one thing is clear: when the next wave of novel coronavirus hits, which it will, the state will be ready.

A shorter version of this article was first published in The Guardian on April 21. This article was updated based on reader feedback.

The views expressed above belong to the author(s). ORF research and analyses now available on Telegram! Click here to access our curated content — blogs, longforms and interviews.


Oommen C. Kurian

Oommen C. Kurian

Oommen C. Kurian is Senior Fellow and Head of Health Initiative at ORF. He studies Indias health sector reforms within the broad context of the ...

Read More +